In the past five years or so, some of our family members involved in family history work learned that there were Connells in Texas that pronounced the last name the same way we do! With a little bit of searching, they found out that we're related.
Turns out that when Granddaddy JC's ancestors moved to South Carolina, they were planning on going much further west. The Connell clan (cousins, aunts, uncles, etc.) was moving from North Carolina and planned on settling somewhere in the West. By the time they reached Lancaster, SC, some of the family got sick and had to stop. The rest of the family kept going while the recuperating ones planned on catching up later. However, the family in Lancaster found a great deal on land right there in South Carolina and decided to stay. I imagine they had also made friends during their extended stay in Lancaster.
When I first heard this story, I imagined it taking place around oh, say 1850. However, the earliest Connell ancestor in South Carolina was born there in 1828, and he had siblings born there as early as 1810. I'm guessing that's about the time the migration took place. It makes sense, because the Louisiana purchase took place in 1803. The Connells were probably thinking to take advantage of all the empty land there.
Before the move, the Connells lived in North Carolina for at least one generation. Before that, they lived in Virginia, all the way back to somewhere between 1625 and 1700. According to the information on Family Search, the next ancestor back came from Renfrewshire, Scotland. Since the surname Connell is usually traced back to Ireland, I wonder if we pronounce our name differently because our ancestors were from Scotland, instead of Ireland? Put your opinion in the comments!
I haven't reviewed any of the sources for the information on this page, so please forgive me if any is incorrect.